7 Silent Christmas Movies (From The Horse-And-Buggy Era)

Do you collect vintage Christmas decorations? Love singing vintage Christmas songs? Maybe even enjoy trying out vintage holiday recipes? Then how about taking the next step and trying out some very vintage Christmas films?

Exposure to forbidding vintage Santas is well worth the price.

I’m not talking about the familiar holiday staples like Miracle on 34th Street, It’s a Wonderful Life or the hallowed classic Santa Claus Conquers the Martians–I’m talking about the very earliest Christmas films ever made, pre-dating our more commercialized era. Heck, they pre-date the widespread use of electricity. The discovery of penicillin. Even the Coca-Cola Santa ClausThese are holiday movies over a century old, from the literal horse and buggy era, and they are charming peeks into a long-gone world. Let’s start with:

7. Santa Claus (1898)

Behold, the oldest surviving Christmas movie ever! It was directed by George Albert Smith, inventor, stage hypnotist, magic lantern lecturer, psychic, and all-around character who is several articles unto himself. It is, of course, very short (although many films at the time were shorter). Don’t be deceived by its primitive look–it contains perhaps the earliest example of two separate scenes happening onscreen at once, tinkering with some of our earliest double-exposure effects. (P.s. Most of the films in this post don’t have background music, because trust me, much of the modern “music” shackled to these poor things is better left to the imagination. Or not even that.)

6. The Christmas Dream (1900)

Leave it to Georges Méliès to help pioneer holiday movies! (Like I always say, every movie trope is 6 degrees of separation from Méliès.) This one contains much frolicking, puffs of fake snow and plenty of those wonderfully vivid painted backdrops and props (I love the giant bell). Keep an eye out for Méliès himself, who appears in two roles.

5. Scrooge, or Marley’s Ghost (1901)

Since we’ve just seen the first Christmas movie ever made, how about watching the earliest screen version of Charles Dickens’s famed novel? This short Walter R. Booth drama was originally about 6 minutes long, although only 3 1/2 minutes survive today. Yes, that does mean the plot of the entire novel was condensed down to a brisk 6 minutes–no small feat! Note the use of double exposures again, as well as Marley substituting for the three ghosts.

4. The Night Before Christmas (1905)

This straightforward short is like being a fly on the wall of genteel Edwardian household on Christmas Eve–you kind of wish you could join them. We switch back and forth from scenes of Santa Claus feeding his herd of reindeer (actually a herd of elk) and working on wooden toys, and several children from a happy city family trying to go to bed and getting so excited that they have a pillowfight instead. If the tiny miniature reindeer and tiny Santa’s sleigh skittering through a painted, miniature snowscape set doesn’t warm the cockles of your heart then I don’t know what can.

3. A Little Girl Who Did Not Believe in Santa Claus (1907)

This little story has a plot twist that will definitely surprise you. (Let’s just say it probably wouldn’t work today.) I love the period detail in this one, from the boy’s Buster Brown-type outfit to the festooned tree to the big teddy bear which today would probably be worth more than my car.

2. A Christmas Carol (1910)

Now for a (moderately) more famous early Christmas Carol movie. In this fine 10 minute Edison drama, Bob Cratchit is played by Charles Ogle, famed for portraying the first screen version of Frankenstein’s monster, and Marc McDermott gives it his all as Ebenezer Scrooge. The scenes are well staged, and the acting is quite good when you consider the fact that many scenes were later filled in with double exposures–the old-timey version of actors using their imaginations with green screens!

…By the way, McDermott was only 29 when he played Ebenezer Scrooge. Yes.

1.The Insects’ Christmas (1913)

This is one of my favorite vintage holiday films, a strange little gem from the great Russian stop-motion animator Ladislas Starevich (spellings vary). He’s credited with being the first person to make an animated puppet film, having made a stop-motion documentary of stag beetles in 1910 using real dead beetles as puppets, posed with bits of wire and sealing wax. He went on to produce a number of surreal films with bug protagonists, like The Grasshopper and the Ant (1911) and The Cameraman’s Revenge (1912). Some folks wondered if he had trained live insects!

I hope you’ve enjoyed this little selection of Victorian and Edwardian Yuletide shorts, and that perhaps they’ll give extra meaning to the phrase “auld lang syne”!

Note: Some of these shorts can be found on Kino’s A Christmas Past DVD, which includes 9 rare, very old holiday films. The music is terrible, but it’s still a nice list.

16 thoughts on “7 Silent Christmas Movies (From The Horse-And-Buggy Era)

  1. I love this post! 😀 I really dig the very early Christmas things. I make it a holiday tradition every year to pull out my Christmas Past set (and wonder if I’m the only person in the world who gets a huge kick out of “A Holiday Pageant at Home”? 🙂 I’ve even gotten used to the music over the years (well, most of it—the jazzed up part in “A Winter Straw Ride” still bothers me some).

    But several of these you’ve posted here were new to me! I’ve not seen either of the Dickens things, or the Melies, so those are new treats. I did run across the 1898 Santa Claus recently, and was glad to see it at the top. Isn’t that the neatest thing—to be able to watch an 1898 Christmas movie? 😀

    • Yes, it really is–and on our smartphones, too! (I’ll watch silents on my phone now and then. There’s a little thrill in thinking how amazed those long-dead filmmakers and actors would be if they knew we’d one day be watching their films on sleek handheld devices whenever we wanted!)

      • Yes, indeed. I often think about that. Here I have an Edison film, made in 1905 with a hand-cranked camera and no electricity, and that camera almost assuredly transported to location on horse and wagon, and I’m watching it—on an iPhone. Is that cool or what? 😀

  2. That last one eeks me out knowing they are dead things that he manipulated and filmed. It’s one of those weird things that are fascinating yet repulsive at the same time! Haha. It’s like a train wreck, you gotta look. The part with the doll moving was amazing, so fluid. I loved A Girl Who Didn’t Believe In Santa Claus. That little part where he takes the doll and decides to put it in the bed with her was especially touching.

    • One of those sweet “bits of business” that silents always did so well! I also like the shot where we see the girl enter her little, snow-covered home–the painted scenery is beautiful, and the rabbit happens to be the same breed as two pet bunnies my family had when I was growing up!

  3. Pingback: Hollywood e os Filmes de Natal – Sociedade Tecnológica

    • Yes, Kino released a set called “A Christmas Past” which includes a lot of the films in this article (and you won’t have to deal with broken YouTube links! 😉 ). I’m not sure if Kino still has it on their site, they might, but you’ll find copies on Amazon.

  4. Pingback: Obscure Films: “Santa Claus” (1925) | Silent-ology

  5. Pingback: Obscure Films: “A Merry Christmas To All” (1926) | Silent-ology

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s