Thoughts On: “His Wedding Night” And “Oh Doctor!”

His Wedding Night (1917)

Title card his wedding night

Comique number four, and number three in terms of Buster Keaton appearances, was the cheekily-titled His Wedding Night–which of course offers nothing salacious. While not usually considered one of Arbuckle’s more outstanding works, it offers loads of fun gags and some “I can’t believe I’m seeing this” Buster scenes. 

Like The Butcher Boy it’s set in a small-town pharmacy called Koff & Kramp, where Roscoe is a kind of clerk-of-all-trades who works the front counter, acts as the soda jerk, and pumps gas for customers outside. Outgoing little Alice Mann plays Roscoe’s sweetheart, and is a welcome addition to the Comique troupe. She and Roscoe make an adorable pair. (I love the shot where they share an ice cream soda.)

Image result for his wedding night 1917

This publicity still was also used to decorate “Sipping Cider Thru’ A Straw” sheet music.

Also like The Butcher BoyHis Wedding Night features Al St. John as Roscoe’s romantic rival, who decides to kidnap Alice and force her into marriage. In his usual Loony Tune villain mode, he both dishes out a bunch of abuse (chewing on characters’ faces in rage!) and receives it (by way of Roscoe and Alice throwing ice cream in his face). There’s a great throwaway gag where he eats watermelon slices with Alice and stops to pick watermelon seeds out of his ears–never fails to get a laugh out of me.

Image result for his wedding night 1917

Image credit: Sales On Film

And Buster? His Wedding Night shows that he was definitely getting comfortable with appearing in films. Again he’s playing a delivery boy, dropping off a wedding dress for Alice. He makes his entrance by crashing into a bike rack and flipping over the handlebars (knocking over a “front porch sitter” gent). In a delightfully subtle bit of detail, Buster somehow pokes himself in the eye during the crash and can’t stop blinking it. Roscoe thinks he’s winking as a sly why of requesting a beer, which he then pours and which Buster then slams.

Image result for his wedding night 1917  buster keaton

Also watch for the shocking contrast between his bare hands and the makeup on his face. Image Credit: Sales On Film

My gosh, Buster fans, if you’ve never seen this short then I am about to change your life. The most weirdly priceless scene is where Buster models the wedding dress for the excited Alice (it’s silent comedy logic, y’all, just roll with it). A folding screen falls to the ground to reveal him dramatically posing in the dress, lit by a spotlight. (I’m quite willing to believe the mechanics of this scene were all Buster’s idea.) He trips about in the pretty dress and it’s glorious. Towards the end Al mistakes him for Alice, throws a pillowcase over his head, and kidnaps him intending to force “her” into marriage. Just in the nick of time Roscoe discovers “Alice” is actually Buster, and in a goofy closeup Buster gives an embarrassed laugh and winks again–apparently he’s still sort of buzzed.

Image result for his wedding night 1917

The creator of The General, everyone.

An interesting trait of His Wedding Night is that the entire premise of the kidnapping scenes depends on the film being silent, and knowing that it’s silent. In a sound film, of course, if Buster’s character got kidnapped all he would have to do is yell and Al would immediately realize he wasn’t Alice. Alice herself would hear the commotion as Buster was being kidnapped, too. This kind of logic can be safely deposited out the window in a silent short.

Now, if you’re looking to play Offensive Material Bingo, His Wedding Night will check off every square. Racially insensitive gags? Check! Awkward gags involving an unconscious woman? Also check! A gag about an effeminate man who just loves ladies’ perfume? You got it! Although some of them, if analyzed, are awkward but fairly harmless, I confess that I usually fast-forward through the gag where Roscoe mischievously kisses a woman who was accidentally knocked out with chloroform (long story). While he plays the scene innocently and we’re not meant to think that his character is on the fast track to becoming a felon, it still leaves me feeling a bit icky.

His Wedding Night screen grab chloroform

Pretty much my face during that scene.

Despite this, there’s a relaxed feel to this short, with the majority of it simply revolving around Roscoe working at the pharmacy and interacting with the various quirky customers that come in. There’s some nice gags showing him mixing ice cream sodas (Roscoe loved scenes involving food preparation–a kitchen was an endless font of creativity for him) and his interactions with Alice are cute and convincing.

Image may contain: 6 people, people standing

All and all, His Wedding Night is a generally enjoyable experience and a lot of people should get a kick out of it. The next short would take a decidedly different turn, as Roscoe, Al and Buster all take roles that are a little out of the Comique norm.

Oh Doctor! (1917)

Title card oh doctor

Alright, I’ll be honest here–of all the Comiques, this is the one I’ve watched the least. It has fewer funny gags than many of the other shorts, fewer slapstick “set pieces,” and less likable characters. And then there’s Buster, who–well, let’s take a closer look at this short first.

Oh Doctor lobby card

Roscoe is well-to-do Dr. I. O. Dine who takes his wife and pampered son (played by Buster!) to see the horse races. Smartly-dressed Al shows up at the track with his vamp-ish, attractive wife. Roscoe secretly flirts with the attractive wife, leading to him saying this strange title card:

Oh Doctor horse race title card

This oddly archaic-sounding card can vary slightly depending on what print you’re viewing, but the gist of it is always the same.  I’m genuinely not sure what its purpose is–is Roscoe trying to act like a pompous intellectual? If so, why doesn’t he say other “intellectual” things too? Is it satirizing something? Did it get inserted later for some odd reason? Anyhoo, both Roscoe and Al lose all their money betting on a losing horse, and one thing leads to another and Al and his wife plot to steal jewelry from the wealthy Roscoe. And of course, their plans go awry.

Being more of a “light comedy” than the other Comiques, Oh Doctor! might also be his closest brush with drama since He Did and He Didn’t (1916). And much like the latter, Roscoe plays a jerky, well-dressed doctor. A really jerky doctor, one who deliberately sticks a pin in his son and who angrily kicks his legs off a table.

Image result for fatty arbuckle buster keaton

Okay, can we talk about Buster now? Because I need to talk about Buster now. If you think his performance in His Wedding Night was uninhibited, you should get a load of Oh Doctor! He doesn’t just smile or laugh, but straight-up bawls with his mouth open wide enough to fit in a tennis ball. It’s just plain disconcerting. I’m sorry, Buster, but you kind of freak me out here.

Buster cries   Oh Doctor  1917

The “humor” in the scenes of Roscoe kicking and smacking his son (which hasn’t worn too well today) might be drawing on the popular trope of “bad boys” like comic strip character Buster Brown. (Fun fact: some say Brown was named after our Buster back when he was a vaudeville child star!) Films and comic strips had plenty of naughty boys who caused mischief and often “pulled one over” on the “old man.” Of course, Buster is supposed to be playing a crybaby brat, not a mischief-maker you’re necessarily supposed to root for. Still, the dysfunctional family of Oh Doctor! certainly fits in with that area of early 20th century pop culture.

Image result for buster keaton laughing

Some say that Buster’s role seems more suited to Al St. John, which does seem true to a point. He sure imitates Al’s, err, enthusiastic acting style, and maybe he decided to experiment with different styles of performing. But I can see why Al stuck to the “straight” role (so to speak). Smooth-faced Buster can pull off a younger character fairly well, and if you think about it, Al was maybe too familiar to contemporary audiences to suddenly be playing a “little boy.”

Oh Doctor lobby card al and gal

Once you get past the Great Buster Distraction, Oh Doctor! offers a chase sequence where Roscoe dresses up as a cop, pursues Al, and busts an illegal gambling ring. The pace is surprisingly measured, perhaps because of the short’s light comedy aspirations. And Roscoe’s character is more likable in the second half–he’s still a cad, but the comedian himself still inserts plenty of funny touches.

Overall, Oh Doctor! is certainly one of the lesser Comiques, with a premise that’s maybe less interesting than the ones in other shorts and with few memorable gags. But it does have high production values, smooth editing, and proves that the ever-creative Arbuckle was willing to mix things up now and then.

My most important source for Comique Month is James Neibaur’s book Arbuckle and Keaton: Their 14 Film Collaborations, published by McFarland. I’ve also been benefiting from the excellent new Blu-ray set Buster Keaton: The Shorts Collection from Kino-Lorber, produced by Lobster Films.

17 thoughts on “Thoughts On: “His Wedding Night” And “Oh Doctor!”

    • Haven’t…seen…all…the Comiques… *faints* Drop everything and start bingewatching right now, Steve!! Everything else can wait. 😀

      Oh yes, I love love LOVE these shorts, but it’s just a fact that many are hits while a few are misses. But it’s also important to remember that even the weaker Arbuckle films are better than many other comedies that were being made at the time.

  1. I’ve just watched these for the first time, and enjoyed them both, actually Oh, Doctor a little more! I liked Buster a lot in the child role role, though I felt sorry for the character. He was also excellent as the kidnapped “bride”.

    Interesting question about the horse card. My guess is maybe Arbuckle or someone else just thought it a funny line, and here was a chance to put it it in. Continuity tidbit: Roscoe puts the police hat on with the emblem facing backwards but it is on frontwards when he emerges on the other side of the door.

    I’m confused about the identity of the actresses in these two. Alice Mann is given as Al’s wife in Oh, Doctor and as Alice in His Wedding Night, but they are clearly not the same – ?

    • I’ve noticed some weirdness with the actor credits, too, and in more than one Comique! In Oh Doctor Alice Mann is the maid in a couple brief scenes, and I’m not sure who’s playing Al’s wife. She’s not Alice Lake and doesn’t look too much like Josephine Stevens. She seems like more of a dramatic actor than a comedienne, too, so maybe she was someone hired just for this film. Oh Doctor’s been very underanalyzed, if you couldn’t tell!

      It looks like several of these films have the wrong actor credits, even in books and on major film sites. Alice Lake is often credited as the maid in The Rough House, but that’s Josephine Stevens. I don’t think Lake showed up at the Comique Film Corporation until Out West, actually. I guess the similar names can complicate things.

      • Whoops, Lake would’ve made her first appearance in our lost A Country Hero, not Out West! Lol, no wonder I got that wrong, eh?

        It makes sense, though, because I think she was working in films in California before Arbuckle moved his Comique company out west. Would have to look at her filmography to be sure, though.

        • All these Alices are confusing. 🙂 If you ever happen to learn who that actually is playing Al’s wife in Oh Doctor, I’d be interested in knowing. She appears to be an excellent comic actress.

      • This Mann/Lake thing is driving me bats. Mann is always listed as The Vamp, but that is not her! She plays the maid whose beau is a large police officer; there is no mistaking her comedic turn in this role. All you have to do is watch His Wedding Night, and her style will be evident.

  2. Pingback: Week of September 29th, 1917 – Grace Kingsley's Hollywood

  3. These movies have been a discovery for me. I was looking for some short films by Buster Keaton and I found these. My nieces are starting to see silent movies and they love Buster, especially the youngest of them (she is 11 years old), so we watch one of her long films weekly and then we will see the short films. And when we finish with his short films we will see those of Roscoe where he appears.
    Seeing Buster with a wedding dress in “His wedding night” is priceless. It’s what I like most about the movie, which in the rest is too crazy for my taste. Buster looks great in women’s clothes (I also love her moment as a blonde ”queen” in ”Backstage”). It makes me laugh when the girl asks him if the dress is not too tight at the waist or chest and Buster says no. They are almost the same size, so it is understandable that she asks you to model her costume. The incomprehensible thing is that Buster agrees so easily. I would have liked the villain to marry Buster, that would have been fun to watch.
    In ” Oh, doctor ” I love soap Hercules: ” Use it every day and you will live until you die. “I want that soap now! But it’s a rather uncomfortable story. It’s not funny to see a man flirting with a vampire in front of his wife, and also it’s not funny to see that man mistreating his little son in different ways and just for pleasure. And how old is the ” child ” Buster? 7, 10, 12 years old?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s