Thoughts On: “Our Dancing Daughters” (1928) and “Our Modern Maidens” (1929)

Are you looking for some fun, frothy movies showing Jazz Age partying in fabulous Art Deco mansions? Are you in the mood for sparkling jewels, immaculate tuxes and flowing champagne? Do you want to see some of those swirling, kaleidoscope shots of musical instruments and dancing couples? Then Our Dancing Daughters (1928) and Our Modern Maidens (1929) are the films for you!

Image result for our dancing daughters

And if you’re among the multitudes who are familiar with Joan Crawford from her 1940s dramas and Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?, then get ready to see the strong-featured, oft-shoulder-padded star as you’ve never seen her–as a sparkling flapper who can beat anyone in a Charleston contest. F. Scott Fitzgerald himself even described Crawford thusly:

Joan Crawford is doubtless the best example of the dramatic flapper. The girl you see at the smartest night clubs–gowned to the apex of sophistication–toying iced glasses, with a remote, faintly bitter expression–dancing deliciously–laughing a great deal with wide, hurt eyes. 

Yup, that Joan Crawford. (From New Movie Magazine, circa 1929-’30.)

In fact, it was Our Dancing Daughters that propelled Crawford to stardom. Prior to working for MGM she had spent years as a chorus girl in touring revues. After moving to California in the mid-1920s and spending some time in bit parts, she decided to get her name out there by frequenting Hollywood parties and dance competitions. She won so many competitions with her energetic Charleston and Black Bottom dances that MGM finally noticed her potential and starting giving her leading roles. The smash hit Our Dancing Daughters was the film that made her a star, as well as a rival to fellow film flappers like Clara Bow. Who’da thunk it?

Image result for our modern maidens

The film’s plot is nothing too original. Crawford’s Diana, a flashy society girl who loves to dance, falls for handsome heir Ben Blaine (Johnny Mack Brown). She’s a moral gal at heart, but Ben doesn’t know this and assumes she must have a “reputation.” Her conniving rival Ann (Anita Page), a gold digger With A Past, decides to woo Ben away from Diana by pretending to be a sweet and virtuous girl. Ben decides to marry the supposedly “suitable” Ann, in spite of his attraction to Diana…and so on and so forth. (I sometimes run across modern reviews complaining how “old-fashioned” the plot is, which makes me chuckle. Put the same plot in a 1950s film and no one bats an eye, but see it in a film from thirty years earlier and people think it’s somehow a surprise.)

Image result for our dancing daughters party

Diana and her sister Beatrice, played by Dorothy Sebastian.

Ah no, the real reason to watch Our Dancing Daughters (as well as Our Modern Maidens) is because it’s gives us the high-society Jazz Age culture of our dreams, where endless fancy parties take place in huge modern mansions and the fringes on beaded dresses fly as “bright young things” dance the Charleston. It’s the quintessential Roaring Twenties, as only Hollywood could create it.

In 2012, America's very wealthiest took their biggest share of the nation's household income since 1928. That was the height of the Roaring '20s - as depicted above in the Joan Crawford film, "Our Dancing Daughters," which came out that year - and the year before the stock market crashed. Since the recession officially ended in June 2009, the top 1 percent enjoyed 95 percent of the income gains. Photo: STF / AP

I think this was also one of the earliest films to showcase Art Deco architecture as the up-to-the-minute trend in modern mansions (rather than as an avant-garde backdrop, as in L’Inhumaine). The sets were designed by the prolific Cedric Gibbons, who became one of cinema’s (all of cinema’s) most important art directors. The vast ballrooms, tall arches and stylized staircases of Our Dancing Daughters are truly eye-popping. The sheer size was certainly Hollywood fantasy, but you wonder if any (smaller) real-life Art Deco homes popped up as a result of films like this. (My practical side assumes they wouldn’t have aged well unless they were kept scrupulously clean and lit just so! Imagine the lines and angles of that one staircase getting little scuff marks over the years.).

Our Modern Maidens is a sequel of sorts to Our Dancing Daughters–or maybe we should called it a follow-up. Joan Crawford and Anita Page are the leading players again, although this time Anita is a girl-next-door type longing for romance. Joan is another dancing socialite, going to the gigantic Jazz parties of our imaginations. Love triangles ensue in another fairly predictable plot, although it does get more daring than its predecessor (of course, it’s nothing that would make us bat an eye today, although it might make some folks incredulously say: “why, this 90-year-old film is kinda old-fashioned!”).

Image result for our modern maidens fairbanks

As with Our Dancing Daughters, it’s worth seeing for those zesty flapper culture scenes (this time we even see people actually drinking from hip flasks), and Douglas Fairbanks Jr., who was newly-married to Crawford at the time. (This naturally resulted in lots of extra publicity for the film.) One of the best scenes has Fairbanks imitating several famous actors–including his superstar father, Douglas Fairbanks Sr.

Image result for our modern maidens fairbanks

Image credit: Immortal Ephemera

Of the two movies, my favorite is probably Dancing Daughters, both for the sights and the surprisingly dramatic ending. But both are well worth watching, and make for a fun and satisfying double feature. They do include those late silent-era soundtracks that include sound effects, which might take a bit of getting used to. But it’s worth it to get to kick back and enjoy a few hours of glamour, as those onscreen flappers and sheiks dance their way through an era we all wish we could visit.

Image result for our modern maidens

A third film in this “franchise” of sorts is Our Blushing Brides, a talkie from 1930 that once again stars Crawford and Page. It may be available on YouTube if you want to check it out!

The Fitzgerald quote (which is often misquoted) is taken from the 1927 article “Has the Flapper Changed?” by Margaret Reid for Motion Picture Magazine. It can be read here

6 thoughts on “Thoughts On: “Our Dancing Daughters” (1928) and “Our Modern Maidens” (1929)

  1. I’ve never seen either of these, and am always thinking “I’ve ought to watch those sometime.” Now this article has given me the shove I needed. Thank you! 🙂

  2. If you want to see earlier Art Deco, see Camille with the inimitable Nazimova and the gorgeous Rudolph Valentino. The set designer was Natacha Rambova, Valentino’s future wife. The sets are breathtakingly exceptional, very exotic pre-Deco period Deco. The visuals, particularly Camille’s apartment, are truly an Art Deco fan’s paradise.

    • Oh, that’s right, I’d forgotten that one. Although to be honest, I like the design in Crawford’s films better–I’m not a fan of the chunky arches or “widely spaced flowers stuck on the walls” look that Rambova came up with. It’s also very much a Nazimova drama, whereas a film like Our Modern Maidens at least pretends to be set in the “real” world (or an exaggeration of it)

  3. I’m watching “Our Dancing Daughters” right now! Dazzling! And everything you said it was.

    Taking what you said a step further (about transplanting the plot into the 50’s and no one would bat an eye)……you could take this plot and put it a movie NOW and no one would bat an eye! It would be the next “Clueless”!

    Man oh man, that Joan Crawford can really dance! I am having an impossible time reconciling 1940s Joan, much less “Baby Jane” Joan with this vivacious free-spirit I’m watching now!

    Great great “Thoughts On….”!

    • Isn’t it amazing, seeing her in those films? I’m sure a lot of people have no idea.

      Yes, aren’t they fun?! They aren’t great works of art (well, maybe the set designs are) but they’re the kind of films you want to kick back and enjoy with a bowl of popcorn (and maybe some champagne!).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s