“The Picture Idol” (1912) And A Nod To Clara Kimball Young

How many of you have gotten to meet a movie star? Not me–despite sightseeing in Hollywood several times now, I have yet to meet (or even glimpse) anyone who’s actually been in movies, naturally. (Not even while wandering Rodeo Drive and daringly deciding to use the bathroom in the Four Seasons hotel–I mean, where else would they be?!) But I guess that’s to be expected. After all, wealthy stars live in fancy gated communities, have top notch security, and go to exclusive restaurants and boutiques and such–no wonder they don’t brush elbows with us commoners very often.

Lobby - Picture of Beverly Wilshire Beverly Hills (A Four Seasons ...

Guess I’ll hang out in the Four Seasons’ lobby next time. Oh, darn.

Ah, but it wasn’t always that way–there was a time that you could brush elbows with a “picture star” at the corner store, or maybe see them walking home from the studio to their little flat just down the block. Want a good example of this more informal era of cinematic stardom? I’d recommend The Picture Idol (1912), one of my favorite light comedies from the genteel Vitagraph studio.

screenshot ThePictureIdol 1912

Reminding us that times haven’t changed too much, it revolves around the teenaged girl Beth’s obsession with screen actor “Howard Hanson” (played by early screen idol Maurice Costello!). She’s so head-over-heels for her hero that she spends more time daydreaming about him than doing her schoolwork or trying to find real-life beaus.

screenshot ThePictureIdol 1912 5

Her parents, witnessing Beth’s plummeting grades and growing collection of Hanson photos papering her bedroom walls, decide to take matters into their own hands. It helps that the father just happens to be friends with Hanson (of course!). Their plan is very much from “a simpler time”–invite the matinee idol over to dinner, where he’ll pretend to have awful table manners, then call on him the next day so the girl can see he has a wife and a brood of rambunctious children. The shock! (Hanson is actually a bachelor so his “wife” is his friend in drag.) Hanson is all for it since he’s getting tired of girls constantly pestering him with love letters and flowers. (Imagine how many flowers someone like George Clooney would get if this were feasible nowadays.)

screenshot ThePictureIdol 1912 3

Clearly appalling–just wait until he starts handing the empty plates to the maid.

The latter strategy is straight outta the early 1910s. Studios back then liked to let audiences think that swoonworthy-actors and actresses were single, even if they were married with several children. Francis X. Bushman is a perfect example–one of the earliest film scandals is when he had an affair with actress Beverly Bayne. This shocked people to their cores, since it was revealed that he was married with several kids (almost as surprising as the affair itself). Girls wanted to dream about their favorites having eyes for them, and them alone–much easier if he’s not someone’s hubby.

The actress playing the teenaged daughter is Clara Kimball Young, who was very popular in both the U.S. and abroad. She was practically born on the stage–both parents were travelling stock actors, she grew up acting in travelling stock as well, and she married a Broadway actor. In 1912 she and her husband broke into moving pictures, getting contracts with Vitagraph.

Clara Kimball Young

Clara’s career was a bit tumultuous, since she had two highly-publicized affairs with producers and also had business-related drama with her company the Clara Kimball Young Film Corporation. She was actually in her twenties during The Picture Idol, but made a convincing school girl. Her expressive, wide-eyed face reminded of Rapunzel from Tangled a few times!

screenshot ThePictureIdol 1912 2

This shot is my favorite part of the film btw.

Clara’s heyday was the 1910s, and while she would continue to work steadily in the following decades she never got back to her former level of stardom. Financial troubles frequently plagued her as well. She would pass away in 1960, apparently after a few years of making it clear she wasn’t interested in talking about the silent days anymore.

Clara Kimball Young | Vintage photo album, Female movie stars ...

By the way, I always love it when these old silents have scenes set in movie theaters–in this case, a small room with folding chairs. Since folks could be meta back then too, we also get to see a spoof of the sort of drama Vitagraph itself liked to make, “starring” one of its own actors.

screenshot ThePictureIdol 1912 4

Is that an actual frame around the screen area? I like it.

Maurice Costello seems to enjoy his role, especially the scenes where he pretends to be a boor. You get the sense he’s playing himself all the way through. In fact, everyone seems to be enjoying themselves in this film–as have I every time I’ve watched it.

Here’s The Picture Idol below, courtesy of the lauded Eye Filmmuseum. The titles are in Dutch, but you can always turn on English closed captions. Enjoy, and know that “simpler times” could be very much real!

12 thoughts on ““The Picture Idol” (1912) And A Nod To Clara Kimball Young

  1. Seems like a cute movie. We’ll probably watch it later. (We lived near L. A. at one point and saw a few celebs entirely by accident, including Richard Burton as he deplaned. If you’re looking for them, they hide).

  2. Even though he was middle-aged and balding, Maurice Costello was THE matinee idol of the 1910s. This very funny film shows us WHY he and CKY were so popular. They both had “IT.” They demonstrate that you don’t have to be an ACTOR to be a Star in silents. As Norma Desmond, silent-film queen, said: “We had faces then.” It was the ability of the actors to express thought and emotions with their facial expressions that made one a Star and another a bit player.

    This film also demonstrates the high photographic quality of these early films. And how enjoyable it is to watch a story told in PICTURES, rather than title cards. We’re fortunate that some of these earliest films have been preserved and are available for viewing – even if only on YouTube. Thanks, Lea, for bringing this little gem to our attention.

  3. After watching ‘The Picture Idol’, I searched for info about CKY and was led to these websites: https://web.stanford.edu/~gdegroat/CKY/home.htm AND https://wfpp.columbia.edu/pioneer/ccp-clara-kimball-young/

    The DeGroat website chronicles the careers of CKY and Norma Talmadge (4 years younger than CKY), both of whom were pioneers in motion pictures. Both apprenticed at Vitagraph. Both reached the pinnacle of stardom. Both were under contract to Selznick pre-1920. But CKY was “through” in the early 20s while Talmadge rose to ever greater heights of popularity until the end of the silent era. The determining factor in the longevity of their careers appears to be the choice of their producers. Talmadge’s producer was her husband, Joseph Schenck,, and CKY’s producer was her paramour, self-serving Harry Garson. In the early 30s, Talmadge, now rich, retired and CKY, due to insolvency, soldiered on, mostly as a bit player in talkies. The story of these 2 female stars and the comparison of their careers is worthy of a book.

  4. Have you checked out the Kennington Bioscope YouTube channel? They’ve started doing a weekly program of silents, and this was on a recent program with piano accompaniment and translated titles. I loved this movie, especially since I just read about the Costello family (there was a lot of drama). Thank you for all the reviews!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s