Thoughts On: “Fatty and Mabel Adrift”

This is the final post for Keystone Month. (Ah, how quickly these 31 days have passed!) A hearty thanks to all of you for dropping in during these past few weeks–I truly hope you’ve been inspired to become as fond of Keystone as I am. And if you’re already a fan, thanks for celebrating with me!

Amid the vast output of silent comedy, there are a few films that can be upheld not only as classics, but as works of art: The General, Our Hospitality, The Kid Brother, City Lights. It’s a worthy list, but one that will always be incomplete without the addition of Roscoe Arbuckle’s charming Fatty and Mabel Adrift.

The poetically-titled three-reeler was directed by Arbuckle for Keystone in its Triangle days and released in 1916 as WWI was roaring across the Atlantic. At the time Arbuckle was one of the biggest names in Hollywood and was being given the freedom to make his films precisely the way he wanted. And what he wanted was as carefully crafted and sophisticated as anything the “art” directors could dream up. Fatty and Mabel Adrift represents a blend of Arbuckle’s innate talent and everything that made Keystone great–charismatic comedians, quality editing, and a slapstick climax whose visuals stick long in your mind.

The opening alone is iconic, establishing the backstory we need with some early special effects. “They lived in Sleepy Hollow,” the title card says. An idyllic countryside scene is overlaid with a heart; the background fades to black as first Mabel’s and then Roscoe’s smiling faces appear inside what are now heart-shaped frames. In one of the most famous images in silent comedy, the hearts entwine to form an image you might see on an antique Valentine’s Day card. But the mood isn’t too syrupy–romantic rival Al St. John’s grinning face also appears inside a heart. Having lost his girl to Roscoe, he cries as the “heart” shatters.

Much of the plot of Fatty and Mabel Adrift is familiar Keystone territory. The country boy falls in love with the pretty farm girl and the two are married in a cute country farm wedding. Her spurned rival vows revenge, which is certain to be carried out somewhat ineptly. What sets it apart from most Keystones is the graceful handling of the story–the short seems more like a mini-feature–and the surprisingly elegant cinematography. Roscoe and his faithful dog Luke (who proves to be pivotal in this film) are silhouetted against the sunset on the sea. The quaint cottage is cozy with firelight. Roscoe peers through the window at a storm amid flashes of lightening. In another iconic image, perhaps the most famous in the film (later paid homage by Buster Keaton in The Navigator), Roscoe’s shadow “kisses” the sleeping Mabel. Ah, my friends, Keystone could be art.

Fatty Mabel Adrift window

Then, of course, there’s the charm of the climax. Al and some fellow rogues sneak through the storm and push the cottage off its foundations and out to sea. We see the interior filling up with water as Roscoe and Mabel slumber unawares in their floating beds. It’s an image both mildly cartoony and purely in the realm of silent comedy.

Fatty and Mabel Adrift is first and foremost a lighthearted film, with plenty of “bits of business” amid piles of hay and around dinner tables with patterned tablecloths. Roscoe and Mabel were audience favorites, teamed up in film after film, and here we can certainly see why. In one scene the newlyweds are trying to eat Mabel’s indigestible cooking, and Roscoe tries unsuccessfully to break apart one of her hard-as-nails biscuits. (He offers it to Luke, who sniffs it once and turns away.) Mabel bursts into tears, and an apologetic Roscoe hugs her–while stealthily smashing a biscuit open so he can make himself eat it and show her that “they aren’t really so bad.”

As the villain, Al St. John seems like the living bridge between the cartoon world and the real. His acting can seem a bit over the top to us today, but it does work within the type of setting where a full-size house can bob on the surface of the sea. He helps support the lighthearted mood–a less caricatured villain menacing the innocent Roscoe and Mabel would not have fit nearly so well.

For decades Roscoe Arbuckle was dismissed as being a lesser clown than Keaton or Lloyd or even some of the minor clowns, thought to have been “loved not so much for what he did as for what he looked like,” as Walter Kerr put it. How that tide is changing today, as his films are being lovingly restored and made more available than ever before. Fatty and Mabel Adrift might be the best example to prove that he was not only a brilliant comedian, but a filmmaker whose eye could be as artistic as any of the Big Three’s.

Fatty and Mabel Adrift is one of the essential silent comedies. It has the sort of greatness that can be classed with Chaplin’s Mutuals or Buster Keaton’s shorts. It’s sweet, timeless, and has a refreshing lack of self consciousness, in spite of its undeniable art.

Fatty Mabel Adrift waving roscoe sunset

The best, and definitive, restoration of this short is on The Mack Sennett Collection Vol. 1., one of my most important resources during Keystone Month. I plug it because I love it!

12 thoughts on “Thoughts On: “Fatty and Mabel Adrift”

  1. Thank you for the enjoyable month of posts, Lea. I have always loved “Fatty and Mabel Adrift.” When I first saw it, some of the artistic touches seemed out of place, but it all hangs together nicely, and I’m always happy when Luke saves the day.

  2. This film is a classic, indeed. The scene I’m most fond of is Fatty breaking up the biscuits to reassure the weeping Mabel. I like your line about Al St. John being a bridge between the cartoon world and the real—that’s a great observation!

  3. I also want to thank you for the interesting articles this month. You may have noticed that I piggybacked on some of your reviews – they were just so good I had to follow up!

  4. Beautifully written, thank you so much! I have come to believe that Arbuckle and Nomand might be the greatest team in all of comedy, they’ve certainly become my own personal favorite….no other team makes you FEEL the way they do! With both bringing out laughs, smart laughs, and always full of surprises. I always watch each film twice: once to catch everything he does, and then everything she does. They are so adorable, beautiful, charismatic…..and best of all, natural. The chemistry between the two was the best and it hurts me very much to hear that it is only in recent years that Arbuckle is getting the credit he deserves. Because his direction – in not just this one, but all the films of his I’ve seen – is always masterful.

    I love how Arbuckle’s persona is not “loser” or “fat slob”….he always seems to get the girl, or has a girl, or has a girl and goes and gets another…….a confident man……a cool dude….. it made my heart sink to see that Walter Kerr quote, that people loved him for how he looked, instead of for how good he was. It’s more like they crucified him for how he looked!! I doubt they would have tried to pin that on, say, Bobby Harron!

    I just finished watching the hysterical, fantastic “Mabel, Fatty and The Law”, and yearned to find a site or something devoted to just the two of them together…..and it led me to this beautiful blog, and this beautiful article….and written so recently! With a whole community of people commenting! I’m practically giddy, and now if you’ll excuse me, I am now going to start reading the entire blog!

    Viva Mabel and Roscoe!!!!

    • Why hello there, kindred spirit! 🙂 Welcome, and feel free to drop in whenever you like!

      Roscoe and Mabel aren’t a bad choice for “Best Comedy Duo”–they complemented each other’s skills beautifully. And there’s so much of the flavor of the era in their work, too. I can completely sympathize with watching each of their films more than once, to catch all the little details they put into their characters! Roscoe in particular was completely underrated by Kerr. Those had to have been some pretty awful prints if “loved for how he looked” was all he took away from those marvelous comedies.

      MAJOR props for mentioning Bobby. He’s without a doubt my favorite dramatic actor from the period!

  5. Pingback: Obscure Films: “A Bear Affair” (1915) | Silent-ology

  6. Just saw this last night on TCM & wow.. Highly enjoyed it. Felt like I was watching a long lost iconic classic. But in reality it seems to be one of the many forgotten silents from the era. This is a film that could have been made today and there wouldn’t be any need to change anything about it. Like you said, timeless.

    Not sure why this wasn’t included in the Arbuckle 4 disc collection but good to know that its included in the Sennett collection.

    • It’s a gem, isn’t it? I’m guessing the Sennett collection was tentatively in the works already, so maybe they “saved” it for that…those DVD sets can take a long time to come together!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s